How to Give Feedback Without Creating Fear on the Manufacturing Floor
A supervisor pulled an employee aside for a “quick correction.”
The feedback was accurate, but the tone was sharp, rushed, and public enough for others to notice.
After that day, the employee stopped asking questions.
Mistakes increased. Engagement dropped.
The leader was confused. “I was just trying to help.”
What’s Really Going Wrong
Feedback delivered without care can unintentionally trigger fear instead of growth.
When people feel embarrassed or threatened, their nervous system shifts into protection mode and learning shuts down.
The People-First Shift
Effective feedback is not about being softer, it’s about being clearer and safer.
Boss Talk: “You’re doing this wrong.”
Guide Talk: “Can we talk about what happened and what we want to see next time?”
A Simple Feedback Framework
Situation: What happened?
Behavior: What was observed?
Impact: Why it matters
Curiosity: “What was going on for you?”
This keeps feedback factual, human, and growth-focused.
Reflection Question for you
How might my tone be affecting how feedback is received?
When feedback builds trust, people don’t shut down, they step up.